Skip to content

Michael Shermer is Concerned

Michael Shermer is concerned.

As if it weren’t bad enough that one of his more famous books is just a paraphrase of Pinker’s The Blank Slate or that his PowerPoint presentations are so awful as to be considered crimes against humanity under the Geneva Convention or that he insists on promoting his libertarianism in every talk, no matter how irrelevant to the topic, he’s apparently taken to concern trolling now.

The facts are these. Shermer wrote a rather bland article about religion and evolution for CNN. Jerry Coyne quoted two paragraphs of Shermer’s conclusion and explained why it represents both an arrogant and unrealistic view of people’s religious beliefs. But he called Shermer an “accomodationist”, which is an apt descriptive term for someone who feels, as Shermer evidently does, that religion and science can coexist — accomodate one another, if you will. In response, Shermer threw a hissy fit about the big, mean Jerry Coyne being a big, mean meany head to him.

At no point in Shermer’s whine does he bother to explain why his position is not, as Coyne claims, profoundly arrogant. He just quotes a couple of commenters and has a good laugh about how superior he is to Jerry Coyne and how enlightened he is, even while he digresses to say that “there is more than one way” and suggests that even the unwashed, unsophisticated, rabid mongrels like Coyne and Dawkins might have a place. There might be some use for that, he says, then quotes someone else who says that Shermer’s approach will “reduce religion’s virulence”. I see that asserted all the time. I’d like some kind of demonstration, at some point, that it actually works.

Because this is the part of Coyne’s post that Shermer ignored to focus on the term “accomodationist”:

Who is Shermer, I suggest, to tell people what beliefs should or should not “matter” to them? Try telling this to a fundamentalist Christian or a devout Muslim. To these folks, scripture is scripture, and it matters that it is true. If, as recent work suggests, prayer doesn’t work, should Shermer tell the faithful that it doesn’t matter whether or not they pray?

That’s a good question. Coyne’s use of fundamentalists for his example was inapt, though. The question applies just as equally to any believer. How is Shermer telling someone, “Oh, you can believe in this kind of god but not that kind of god?” any better than what Shermer sees as Coyne’s “head-on, take-no-prisoners, full-frontal assault”. How is it any less offensive? I’d argue it’s not. It’s just that Coyne and Dawkins and PZ Myers have the honesty to admit what they genuinely believe — that there is not evidence for the existence of a god — rather than pussyfooting around it saying, “Well, I don’t think there is, but you can think there is, and I won’t say anything about that as long as you believe everything else I think you should.”

The bottom line is, Shermer’s mockery is all out of proportion with the fact that Coyne raised a good point. And for that matter, Shermer doesn’t acknowledge the fact that he is, in fact, despite his own protestations to the contrary, attempting to dictate what is and is not an acceptable form of religious belief. Which is fine, if for fuck’s sake you just have the integrity to admit that you’re doing it.

  • http://www.sunclipse.org Blake Stacey

    I think one of your hyperlinks was meant to point to Jerry Coyne’s post.

    I remember Shermer reading this, or something effectively equivalent to it, when he visited Harvard to book-talk his Why Darwin Matters:

    If one is a theist, it should not matter when God made the universe — 10,000 years ago or 10 billion years ago. The difference of six zeros is meaningless to an omniscient and omnipotent being, and the glory of divine creation cries out for praise regardless of when it happened.

    Oddly enough, it was at that exact moment when my brain realized that it shouldn’t expect any profound insights into the human condition from this Shermer fellow.

  • http://tobascodagama.com Joshua

    Yikes, I also used the wrong image entirely. Fixed both errors. Now we have a happy little LOLshermer to lead off the post.

    Anyway, I recall attending the same talk and being similarly unimpressed, though I can’t say quite so precisely what part of the talk unimpressed me the most.

    It was his TAM6 talk (which is to say, “PowerPoint recitation“) that really put me off the guy forever.

  • http://www.sunclipse.org Blake Stacey

    On the subject, had you read this from a few months ago?

  • http://tobascodagama.com Joshua

    I hadn’t, I don’t think, but I definitely will now.

online prescription Orlistat buy generic finpecia finpecia online uk buy prednisone for cheap buy prednisone uk order Metformin online Metformin espana non prescription prednisone lisinopril prednisone with no rx lisinopril buy Orlistat pills Finpecia dose online|Finpecia 1 mg order online|Finpecia generic vs propecia|Finpecia cost australia|buy generic Finpecia uk|purchase Finpecia uk|buy Finpecia online prescription|buy generic Finpecia 1mg|buy Finpecia|Finpecia online australia|buy Finpecia no prescription uk|order Finpecia 1mg|buy Finpecia cheap|Finpecia generic 1mg|Finpecia online prescription|Finpecia 1mg generic canada|Finpecia costco pharmacy|Finpecia 1mg india|Finpecia generic walmart|buy Finpecia no prescription forum|buy Finpecia online australia|Finpecia online uk) buy Orlistat diet pill buy Finpecia 1 mg no prescription online|buy cheap Finpecia online|order Finpecia|Finpecia generic walmart|Finpecia online prescription|buy Finpecia 1mg online|Finpecia generic online|Finpecia costco price|order Finpecia online|buy Finpecia 1mg malaysia|purchase Finpecia uk|topical Finpecia buy|Finpecia 1 mg order online|Finpecia generic|buy Finpecia online canada|Finpecia 1 mg order online|Finpecia online india|Finpecia generic 1 mg|order Finpecia uk|Finpecia depression women|buy cheap Finpecia 1mg|Finpecia generic names|legal buy Finpecia online|Finpecia depression women|buy Finpecia 1mg india|Finpecia generic walmart|buy Finpecia 1mg online|Finpecia online india|buy Finpecia 1mg online|Finpecia 1mg tablets|Finpecia costco price|order Finpecia canada|buy Finpecia online australia|Finpecia dose hair|buy Finpecia online paypal|Finpecia 1mg|Finpecia 1mg for sale|Finpecia online uk|buy Finpecia uk|Finpecia 1mg vs 1mg|Finpecia generic walmart|Finpecia costco pharmacy|buy Fin Lisinopril without rx medikament Lisinopril purchase cheap Maxalt onlinebuy next day Maxalt how to buy finpecia online lisinopril cheap prednisone without a prescription what is Metformin Metformin pricing where to buy generic finpecia free Orlistat buy Metformin in mo comprar Metformin generico buy finpecia offshore no prescription fedex Orlistat cheap mexican buy Orlistat 120mg buy Premarin amex online buy Orlistat online no prescription buy Buspar fed ex Lisinopril order online Premarin buy cod where to purchase generic Premarin online without a rx buy Metformin doctor prescription Amitriptyline 75mg http://www.adefagironde.org/ buy brand Orlistat uk buy Metformin buy Metformin online without prescription Orlistat for sale buy finpecia no prescription buy Metformin online us pharmacy (prednisone overnight without prescription|how to order prednisone online without a prescription|prednisone without prescriptions in usa|cheapest prednisone|buy prednisone over the counter|prednisone order online|cheap prednisone online no prescription|buy generic prednisone no prescription|prednisone buy cheap|prednisone generic|prednisone no prescription with mastercard|no prescription generic prednisone|prednisone no prescription needed|prednisone express online|purchase generic prednisone online|prednisone from mexico|prednisone online no prescriptions required from the US|prednisone cheap online canadian pharmacy|canadian generic prednisone no prescription|how to get prednisone online no prescription in 20 days|purchase prednisone online|prednisone generic sale|prednisone buy online without rx|wholesale prednisone|prednisone 40 mg without a prescription|prednisone without rx|prednisone without script|prednisone purchase canada|prednisone cheap online|b Premarin no prescription to buy purchase Amitriptyline without a prescription online buy Buspar online overseas buy cheap Metformin online free consult Metformin costs order Metformin online Premarin order Metformin capsule