Skip to content

Good Vibrations: Revising My Opinion of String Theory

I’ve generally had a view of String Theory well-encompassed by this fabulous XKCD strip. However, Cosmic Variance has a couple of really interesting posts defending String Theory that I find, if not entirely convincing, at least intriguing enough to warrant a second thought.

Let’s start with this one, the oldest of the three articles I read there. It gives a pretty good summary of how string theory came about and why it’s the most promising theory in advanced physics right now. More importantly for me, it answers the “What does that imply?” question from XKCD:

Once you set off down this road, you are are inevitably led to a remarkably rich structure: extra dimensions, gauge theories, supersymmetry, new extended objects, dualities, holography, and who knows what else. Most impressively of all, you are led to gravity: one of the modes of a vibrating string corresponds to a massless spin-two particle, whose properties turn out to be that of a graviton. It’s really this feature that separates string theory from any other route to quantum gravity.

Hey, neat! Granted, we didn’t need string theory to infer the existence of gravity, but the interesting bit is that we can derive a string that looks exactly like a graviton from a more fundamental basis. Sean points out that most other theories for quantum gravity start with the gravity as we know it and work down from there, trying to force it to quantise. String theory, by Sean’s description, derives gravity from the bottom up, already quantised.

Ok, I’m listening. Do go on.

The next article I saw was this one. It reiterates the gravity-prediction quality above, but gives more of a historical background on how exactly string theory got to its current position of dominance. There’s not the “Oh, duh” moment of the previous one, but there’s good information for anyone interested, arguments for both pro and con, as well as links to some current (as of last summer) research.

And then there’s this more recent post, where Sean responds to a recent Bloggingheads dialogue that trashed string theory. He also brings up some points that get lost in the transition from academia to the public. The fact that scientists have vocal disagreements over theories says nothing about the theories themselves. That’s just how science works, and we shouldn’t want it any other way.

I do have to take a small exception, however. Sean mentions evolution as a response to Peter Woit’s statement that “things are not looking good for a physical theory when there start being public debates on the subject”. The substance of Sean’s criticism of that statement is quite correct — whether or not there’s a public debate has little to do with the scientific accuracy of a theory — but I personally wouldn’t be so quick to equate debates over string theory with debates over evolution. The fact is that string theory has not yet reached a significant level of acceptance among scientists, and is still in its infancy, whereas evolution is a theory with roots 150 years old confirmed by myriad strands of evidence that has withstood several field-shaking discoveries since its conception, including the early genetic revolution that led to the Neo-Darwinian synthesis.

String theory has yet to experience such a trial by fire, but that’s not a bad sign. Only time will tell whether it ends up like Lamarck’s theory, viewed historically as an important but ultimately incorrect first step, or like Darwin’s, a vital unifying theory that spawns hundreds of years of fruitful new research.

Either way, Sean’s arguments have convinced me that string theory probably deserves some more time to work itself out before we start passing judgement on it. Especially those of us in the general public.

online prescription Orlistat buy generic finpecia finpecia online uk buy prednisone for cheap buy prednisone uk order Metformin online Metformin espana lisinopril prednisone with no rx lisinopril buy Orlistat pills Finpecia dose online|Finpecia 1 mg order online|Finpecia generic vs propecia|Finpecia cost australia|buy generic Finpecia uk|purchase Finpecia uk|buy Finpecia online prescription|buy generic Finpecia 1mg|buy Finpecia|Finpecia online australia|buy Finpecia no prescription uk|order Finpecia 1mg|buy Finpecia cheap|Finpecia generic 1mg|Finpecia online prescription|Finpecia 1mg generic canada|Finpecia costco pharmacy|Finpecia 1mg india|Finpecia generic walmart|buy Finpecia no prescription forum|buy Finpecia online australia|Finpecia online uk) buy Orlistat diet pill buy Finpecia 1 mg no prescription online|buy cheap Finpecia online|order Finpecia|Finpecia generic walmart|Finpecia online prescription|buy Finpecia 1mg online|Finpecia generic online|Finpecia costco price|order Finpecia online|buy Finpecia 1mg malaysia|purchase Finpecia uk|topical Finpecia buy|Finpecia 1 mg order online|Finpecia generic|buy Finpecia online canada|Finpecia 1 mg order online|Finpecia online india|Finpecia generic 1 mg|order Finpecia uk|Finpecia depression women|buy cheap Finpecia 1mg|Finpecia generic names|legal buy Finpecia online|Finpecia depression women|buy Finpecia 1mg india|Finpecia generic walmart|buy Finpecia 1mg online|Finpecia online india|buy Finpecia 1mg online|Finpecia 1mg tablets|Finpecia costco price|order Finpecia canada|buy Finpecia online australia|Finpecia dose hair|buy Finpecia online paypal|Finpecia 1mg|Finpecia 1mg for sale|Finpecia online uk|buy Finpecia uk|Finpecia 1mg vs 1mg|Finpecia generic walmart|Finpecia costco pharmacy|buy Fin Lisinopril without rx medikament Lisinopril purchase cheap Maxalt onlinebuy next day Maxalt how to buy finpecia online lisinopril cheap prednisone without a prescription what is Metformin Metformin pricing where to buy generic finpecia free Orlistat buy Metformin in mo comprar Metformin generico buy finpecia offshore no prescription fedex Orlistat cheap mexican buy Orlistat 120mg buy Premarin amex online buy Orlistat online no prescription buy Buspar fed ex Lisinopril order online Premarin buy cod where to purchase generic Premarin online without a rx buy Metformin doctor prescription Amitriptyline 75mg buy brand Orlistat uk buy Metformin buy Metformin online without prescription Orlistat for sale buy finpecia no prescription buy Metformin online us pharmacy Premarin no prescription to buy purchase Amitriptyline without a prescription online buy Buspar online overseas buy cheap Metformin online free consult Metformin costs order Metformin online Premarin order Metformin capsule